Behind the practice

The questions people are embarrassed to ask a dietitian

By Nicola (Nikki) Edwards-Kalaf · 13 October 2026

A person sitting at a kitchen bench with a cup of tea, looking thoughtful rather than anxious, photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Nobody tells you the quiet questions are normal

Most people who think about seeing a dietitian do a surprising amount of thinking before they ever send an email. Not about the food part. About the other part. Will I have to give up the things I actually like? Will someone look at what I eat and quietly judge it? Do I need to already be eating well before I'm allowed to book, as if turning up a mess is somehow against the rules?

These questions rarely get asked out loud, which means they rarely get answered. So here they are, answered plainly, the way you'd want a straight talking friend to answer them rather than a brochure.

Do I have to give up the things I like

No. A dietitian's job is not to confiscate your favourite foods. General nutrition guidance works with what you already eat and how you already live, not against it. If a genuine health condition means certain foods need particular attention, that is a conversation for you and your own GP or treating practitioner, worked out for your specific situation rather than a blanket rule handed to everyone who walks in the door.

For almost everyone else, the starting point is your actual week. What's in the fridge, what the school run looks like, what you reach for at 3pm on a Thursday. The aim is to find small, sustainable adjustments that fit a real life, not a complete rebuild of how you eat. If an appointment feels like it's asking you to abandon everything you enjoy, that's a sign something has gone wrong with the conversation, not a sign you're doing it right.

Will I be judged for what I eat now

This one sits heavier than people admit. Plenty of adults can recite exactly what they had for breakfast with a flinch already built in, bracing for a reaction. A dietitian's role is to understand your current pattern clearly enough to work with it, not to hand out a verdict on it. Nobody needs a lecture about the frozen meals in the freezer or the fact that dinner was toast three nights this week. That information is simply useful, not shameful.

Honesty about your week only works if it's safe to be honest. A good consultation treats what you're currently doing as the baseline, not the crime scene. The tinned tomatoes, the service station pie, the cereal for dinner, all of it is data, and data doesn't need an apology attached.

Do I need to be "doing well" before I book

This is probably the most common unspoken reason people put off booking for years. There's a strange belief that you should arrive with your eating already mostly sorted, as though turning up with chaos is an admission of failure. It's the reverse of how it actually works. People come in at every possible starting point, from someone who hasn't cooked a vegetable in a fortnight to someone managing a fairly settled routine who wants to fine tune one part of it.

There is no entry requirement. You don't need a food diary, a clean pantry, or a tidy explanation for why things slipped. If you're curious about how an appointment actually runs before you commit to one, that's exactly what the work with me page is there to show you, so nobody has to book blind just to find out what they're booking.

What about cost, Medicare and whether I even qualify

This question gets tangled up in embarrassment too, because people assume asking about cost makes them sound like they're not serious. It doesn't. It makes you sensible. Here are the plain facts. A dietitian is not a protected title you can simply claim, but it is the legally protected one in Australia, and it means a health professional has completed a minimum of four years of full time study covering subjects such as anatomy, physiology, biochemistry and medical nutrition therapy. The Accredited Practising Dietitian credential, or APD, sits on top of that qualification, and APDs are the only recognised nutrition professionals able to provide dietetic services under Medicare, the Department of Veterans' Affairs, and most private health funds.

As for Medicare specifically, a rebate is only available through a GP chronic condition management plan, and a patient with a plan may be eligible for up to five individual allied health and wellbeing services per calendar year, a limit shared across every allied health professional on that plan, not five visits per practitioner. That system exists for people managing an ongoing condition, and whether it applies to you is a decision for your GP, not something to self diagnose from a website. If you want the detail laid out without the jargon, the rebates page walks through how it actually works.

The short version

Nobody should have to overcome a wall of embarrassment just to find out how an appointment works. You don't need to give anything up before you're allowed to ask a question, you won't be judged for the state of your current eating, and you don't need to arrive "ready". If any of this has been the thing quietly stopping you, the honest next step is simply to look at what an appointment involves and decide from there, which is exactly what the work with me page sets out to do.

Filed under Behind the practice · all articles

Bookings

The good stuff is free, it just knows your name

Full recipes, sample days and the weekly letter, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.